Welcome to our tasting notes for pairing port with Stilton cheese. This is a favourite of cheese lovers throughout the world.
Below are tasting notes for the cheese, the spirit and comments on how they pair together. At the bottom of this section, there are more detailed notes for you to explore the cheese and wine more completely.
Your cheese is ripe Stilton aged around 3 months.
Body | Creamy, smooth, dense, slightly crumbly. Firm yet velvety mouthfeel, with blue veining adding contrasting granularity. |
Primary Tastes | Noted savoury/umami, some saltiness, subtle sweetness Herbal bitterness is important |
Dairy Flavors | Cream and butter |
Making Flavors | Piquancy, mushroom and earthy quality Earthy Ripe pear or dried fruit |
Aging Flavors | Stilton is not typically aged beyond ripening – intensified savoury, umami, and earthy notes – tang from the excessive blue – butterscotch or caramel – gritty calcium salts in the blue veins |
Your wine is a port.
Body | Full-bodied. Thick and velvety, dominated by sweetness, but slightly astringent tannins and 20% to 22% alcohol though well-integrated and not dominant. |
Grape Flavors | Dark fruit flavors, blackberry, black cherry, and plum prominent. |
Aging Flavors | Dried Fruits: raisins, dates, and figs Spice: such as cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves Nuts and caramel Earthy, tobacco, and leathery notes |
The weight and intensity of the wine is key to its positive impact and character.
Remember – everyone is different so you will have your own opinions.
However, this is one of the most reliable cheese and wine pairings.
Strength | Both have robust and intense big-bodied flavor profiles. In addition, the alcohol cuts through the creamy curd. |
Balance | The wine is sweet and the cheese salty savoury, providing the core balance and matching in the pairing. |
Harmony | Slight: nuttiness of the cheese very lightly bridges to the nuttiness that comes from aging the port. Some unexpected flavors: chocolate, fondant, black forest gateau. |
Texture | The viscous port melds nicely with the cheese softening in the mouth. |
Provenance | Port and Stilton have been pairing together in the UK through accidents of war and trade since the 18th century. One of the most iconic cheese and wine pairings. |
In 1724, Daniel Defoe wrote in his “Tour Through The Villages of England & Wales” of Stilton being “famous for cheese,” calling it the “English Parmesan.” What this means is not at all clear, and could refer simply to it being England’s signature cheese without referring to its flavor, but it created a sensation. John Lawrence, in 1726, describes “recently famous Stilton” as “about 7 inches in diameter, 8 inches in height and 18 lbs in weight.” This is a similar shape, but about half the weight of a modern stilton. Stilton is going viral.
Blue Stilton does not become a thing until it is taken up by a publican Cooper Thornhill of the Bell Inn, Stilton. The town is in Cambridgeshire on the Great North Road from London to Edinburgh. Stilton is not and was not made in Stilton. Stilton and The Bell Inn is what made the cheese famous, but the making of it is the story of three women.
Lady Beaumont of Elton Hall made Stilton cheese for her own family’s use in the 1600s, and tales abound of her secret recipe. It was a Mrs. Orton, wife of a farmer from Little Dalby, who claimed to have made the first commercial Stilton cheeses in Leicestershire in 1730. The third lady, Frances Pawlett, a cheese-maker hailing from Wymondham in Leicestershire, strikes a deal with Thornwill to make the cheese and Pawlett’s develops a unique recipe for Stilton. Her recipe coalesces the blue cheeses made in Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire into Stilton.
During the 19th century, Stilton production expanded significantly. Railways improved transportation, making it easier to distribute the cheese throughout England and beyond. The cheese became a favourite among the British upper class and gained recognition through awards and accolades at various exhibitions.
In 1996, Stilton cheese was granted PDO status by the European Union, recognizing its unique heritage and production methods. This legal protection ensures that only cheese produced in specific regions of England (Leicestershire, Derbyshire, and Nottinghamshire), and adhering to traditional methods, can bear the name “Stilton.” Crucially, Stilton must be pasteurised to carry the name. This is as contentious as pasteurisation is a 20th century innovation. Some continue to believe true Stilton should not be pasteurised and it is a wrong that raw milk cheeses cannot bear that name. However, as we have seen, Stilton has always changed to make better cheese.
Stilton & America (19th-20th Century)
Stilton cheese started making its way to America in the 19th century, thanks to the growing British influence in the United States. American epicures, inspired by European culinary traditions, began to develop a taste for Stilton and other British cheeses. Importers began to ship Stilton across the Atlantic, introducing it to American cheese connoisseurs.
In the early 20th century, Stilton cheese gained further recognition in America as it was featured in prestigious restaurants and cheese shops. It became a then-symbol of sophistication and a must-have on fine dining menus.
Smaller Stilton may be produced for Christmas, and it is traditional to sell it in ornate jars. For jarred Stilton, beware of the cheese being pressed into the jar, as this can ruin the texture.
Stilton cheese can be poorly made, with excessive bitterness, dryness, mostly dairy notes, but otherwise lacking in complexity. At its best, it can be the best cheese in the world.
Port dates to the late 17th century in the Douro Valley, northern Portugal. The Douro Valley’s diverse terroir and a rich variety of grape types, including Touriga Nacional, Touriga Franca, and Tinta Roriz, provided the raw materials for the creation of exceptional wines.
What makes port different from a typical wine is the adding brandy part way through fermentation. This makes it a “fortified” wine. Adding the high alcohol spirit kills the yeast and prevents the last sugars being consumed, delivering the twin characteristics of port – higher sweetness and high alcohol.
The wine first captured the attention of British wine enthusiasts in the late 1600’s and they embraced it. In 1703, the Treaty of Methuen, also known as the Port Wine Treaty, was signed between Portugal and England. This treaty significantly reduced the tariffs on Portuguese wines entering England, leading to a boom in Portuguese wine. This was exacerbated due to the periodic conflicts between England and France, including the Napoleonic Wars. During these conflicts, trade with France was disrupted, leading to an increased demand for Portuguese wines, particularly port.
To meet this trade, British wine merchants, such as John Croft and John Graham, established themselves in the Douro Valley, contributing to the production and exportation of port wine.
In 1756, the Marquis of Pombal, Sebastião José de Carvalho e Melo issued a royal charter known as the “Alvará De 10 De Setembro,” which established the Douro Valley as the world’s first officially demarcated and regulated wine region.
British merchants introduced innovations, including the classification of port wines into the production process. In the 20th century, the categorization of Vintage, LBV (Late Bottled Vintage), and Tawny Ports emerged. Winemakers began experimenting with different styles of port, including white port and rosé port, to cater to evolving tastes. Port wine also saw the emergence of Single Quinta (Vineyard) Vintage Ports.
The USA: An Emerging Market For Port Wine
Early American colonists had a taste for fortified wines, including port, madeira and sherry. In recent decades, the United States has witnessed a resurgence of interest in port wine. It has become a favored after-dinner drink, appreciated for its rich, sweet, and complex flavors. Mixologists have also embraced port wine as an ingredient in cocktails, given its moderate alcohol, strong fruit flavors, viscosity and most importantly its natural sweetness.
Ruby port, often described as the “youngest” port, is a vibrant red color with fruit-forward flavors. After fortification, ruby ports are aged in large oak vats for a short period, usually around 2 to 3 years. This limited aging preserves the wine’s bright fruit flavors and deep red color.
Tawny port is elegant, complex, with intriguing nutty notes. They are aged in smaller oak barrels or casks, exposing the wine to oxygen over an extended period. This oxidative aging changes the colour of the wine to tawny or amber, makes it smoother and brings notes of nuts, dried fruits, toffee and caramel.
Tawny ports are often blended from different vintages and casks, creating a consistent house style. The age designation on the bottle (e.g., 10-year, 20-year, or 40-year) indicates the average age of the blended wines.
Late Bottled Vintage (LBV) Port offers a compromise between the vibrant fruitiness of a ruby port and the complexity of a vintage port. LBV ports are aged longer in wood barrels, typically 4 to 6 years, before bottling. This extended aging allows them to develop more complexity and character compared to ruby ports.
LBV ports are characterized by their rich, fruity flavors, often with notes of dark berries, plums, and a touch of spice. They are approachable, well-structured, and a great choice for both immediate consumption and cellaring.
Vintage port is often considered the crown jewel of the port world, representing the pinnacle of quality and aging potential. Crafting a vintage port involves meticulous attention throughout the make process.
Vintage ports generally require decanting to remove the sediment before drinking.
Tasting Notes For Vintage Port Wine
Vintage port is a sumptuous and powerful wine with a rich array of flavors and a well-balanced profile. While it is not subjected to modern flavoring techniques, its extended bottle aging leads to a fascinating evolution of flavors that make it a true treasure for wine enthusiasts.
Comparable Strengths: Both vintage port and blue Stilton have robust and intense big-bodied flavor profiles. The powerful, sweet, and fruity notes of vintage port complement the rich savory and salty character of blue Stilton cheese, and the alcohol breaks through the fatty curd.
Balance of Tastes: The wine is sweet and the cheese salty savoury, giving a nice balance. The unusual aspect is the bitterness. For bitter Stiltons, the ports dampens it, as is expected and welcomed. However, with finely balanced Stiltons, its bitterness can be strengthened in a herbaceous or leafy way, increasing the complexity of the marriage.
Harmony of Flavors: There some harmony in the nuttiness of the cheese and the nuttiness that comes from aging the port, but this is slight. The matching is primarily in the body and tastes.
Textural Combination: The vicous port melds nicely with the cheese softening in the mouth.
Provenance: Port and Stilton arise at the same time, the late 17th and early 18th century. While port is Portuguese, many of the port houses arise from British merchants and port and Stilton rose in popularity in a parallel way. This has led to this classic combination being cherished for generations, reflecting the British appreciation for both fine yet accessible cheese and wine.